Some Kind of Hate (2015): Whereas I thought that director
Adam Egypt Mortimer’s follow-up film Daniel Isn’t Real (perhaps later
more about that one on a later date) was a brilliant horror film about mental
illness and the idea of “normality”, this, Mortimer’s first feature really
doesn’t work at all. This one’s about the trauma of bullying and an undead girl
taking vengeance on bullies and taking things rather too far. Apart from obvious
structural problems like terrible pacing and way too much repetition, what this
one suffers under most is a certain heart on its sleeve quality that suggests
filmmakers a bit too close to the theme they want to talk about and
therefor unable to step away from it enough to turn it into functioning art. A
couple of the kills are pretty cleverly staged and imagined, at least, but it’s
clear throughout that the film has much greater ambitions than being a slash
fest it simply can’t fulfil.
Meek’s Cutoff (2010): Kelly Reichardt’s revisionist
(post-revisionist?) Western on the other hand seems to be able to fulfil all of
its ambitions easily, but then the comparison between a debut horror movie by a
young guy just starting out and an experienced director like Reichardt at the
top of her game is completely unfair of me, probably to both films. Anyway,
Reichardt’s ambitions here are many: at once to show a naturalistic,
detail-focussed tale of settlers on the Oregon trail but also to sip from the
mythic well that has been built over the bones of such settlers; talking about
America today by talking about its past; facing the complexities of societal
misogyny and racism head-on. She’s doing all that in a film shot with some of
the starker values of post 2000s US indie cinema – the very digital camerawork,
the realistic sound (though leave it to Reichardt to make it a highly
constructed realistic sound clearly designed), the paucity of a
classical dramatic plot, the slow pacing. Which shouldn’t work terribly well at
all, but in practice, the whole film has a nearly magical quality of slowly
growing intensity and will eventually feel at once naturalistic and utterly not
of this world.
The Ladykillers (1955): And now for something completely
different, a classic British black comedy about criminals and old ladies by
Alexander Mackendrick (made for Ealing Studios who had a bit of form for this
sort of thing) that’s about as subversive about society, to be precise about how
a classist society reads social cues and roles and the way this twists even the
people who think themselves clever enough to use this for their own profit, as
can be.
It’s classically stylish British comedy cinema of this type, with actors like
Alec Guiness, Katie Johnson, Cecil Parker, a young Peter Sellers, or Herbert Lom
treating their roles with an arch humour that never can quite disguise the
actual humanity behind characters that aren’t treated terribly compassionately
by the film they are in.
Saturday, March 7, 2020
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment